Expert’s Best Deer Attractant For Succesful Deer Hunting [2023 Update]

FP7 Hunt is reader supported and may earn a commission when you purchase using our affiliate links

The best deer attractant can bait deer right into your sights. But, just so you know, not every so-called attractant can actually do its job.

But worry not; I’ve done the heavy lifting and tested a bunch of them for you.

So, take a look at my top picks for the best deer attractant that can significantly increase your hunting victories. These range from deer urine, mineral supplements, and attractant blocks.

Best Overall
Nationwide Scents Buck Urine
9.8
  • Net Weight: 8.0 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Buck Urine
  • Effectivity: 5/5
  • Price: 3/5
Runner Up
Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic
9
  • Net Weight: 72 oz 
  • Flavor/Scent: Natural Molasses
  • Effectivity: 4/5
  • Price: 3/5
Best Budget
Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic
8
  • Net Weight: 70 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Apple
  • Effectivity: 3/5
  • Price: 5/5
FP7 Hunt is reader supported and may earn a commission when you purchase using our links

Top Deer Attractant on the Market

Getting straight to the point, here are my top picks on the market today:

Nationwide Scents Buck Urine

Nationwide Scents Buck Urine
Best Overall

Nationwide Scents Buck Urine

  • Net Weight: 8 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Buck Urine

You'll be blown away by the potency of Nationwide Scents Buck Urine, a deer attractant so powerful it's like having a secret weapon in your hunting arsenal. 

This whitetail deer attractant is no ordinary product; it's a meticulously crafted scent eliminator designed to mask your human scent in the field. The secret behind its effectiveness is fresh deer urine. 

With Nationwide Scents' state-of-the-art stainless-steel collection facilities and over 500 live whitetail deer, they produce a deer urine formula that surpasses USDA and ATA Deer Protection Guidelines. That ensures you're getting the most potent deer scent blocker available.

The best advice when using this? Start using it on your mock scrapes as early as May or June. By freshening your scrapes with Buck Urine throughout the hunting season, you'll keep your target bucks returning, enhancing your chances of a successful hunt.

 

Pros
  • Highly potent and effective
  • Can be used throughout the hunting season 
  • Exceeds industry standards for deer protection
Cons
  • Requires regular application for best results 

Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic

Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic
Runner Up

Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic

  • Net Weight: 72 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Natural Molasses

Imagine the thrill of seeing those majestic creatures drawn in and returning over and over, entranced by the irresistible scent of Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic. 

This 72 oz bag of natural molasses-flavored mineral supplement is not just any deer attractant. It's a powerful powder formula that soaks deep into the ground for a long-lasting effect and begins working immediately upon application.

Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic is a proven favorite among deer with its enhanced molasses flavor. The deer not only visit but also keep coming back, forming hard trails leading to the mineral site.

Once you open the bag, you'll instantly sense the strong, alluring aroma that makes this product a powerful deer attractant. It functions year-round, making it an excellent choice for maintaining active mineral sites regardless of the season.

Pros
  • Quick effect
  • Begins working immediately upon application 
  • Effective year-round
Cons
  • The strong scent might not appeal to all hunters
  • Powder form may require careful handling to avoid waste

Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed

Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed
Best Budget

Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed

  • Net Weight: 70 oz
  • Flavor/Scent:Apple

With Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed, you're not just setting out bait but providing a nutritional supplement that keeps the local wildlife robust and returning for more. 

This ready-to-use mineral deer attractant possesses attractive power to lure deer into your desired site. Also, it has been fortified with phosphorus and calcium, giving deer in your hunting area extra nutrition to keep them strong and healthy.

This long-lasting block combines a health-promoting mineral and salt mixture with an intense ripe apple aroma and flavor that deer can't resist.

Despite being cheap, it maintains its effectiveness throughout the hunting season, making it a perfect choice for those who don’t want to spend loads of pennies. 

Pros
  • It offers an intense apple aroma and flavor that deer love 
  • Convenient and easy to use 
  • Provides extra nutrition for deer 
  • Cheapest in the market
Cons
  • Block form may not be as potent as the powder or liquid form
  • It may not last as long in areas with high deer populations 

Buck Nut Acorn Cover Scent

Buck Nut Acorn Cover Scent
Best Cover Scent

Buck Nut Acorn Cover Scent

  • Net Weight: 8 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Acorn, Apple, Pine or Dirt

With Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed, you're not just setting out bait but providing a nutritional supplement that keeps the local wildlife robust and returning for more. 

This ready-to-use mineral deer attractant possesses attractive power to lure deer into your desired site. Also, it has been fortified with phosphorus and calcium, giving deer in your hunting area extra nutrition to keep them strong and healthy.

This long-lasting block combines a health-promoting mineral and salt mixture with an intense ripe apple aroma and flavor that deer can't resist.

Despite being cheap, it maintains its effectiveness throughout the hunting season, making it a perfect choice for those who don’t want to spend loads of pennies. 

Pros
  • Excellent cover scent
  • Long-lasting
  • Effective odor eliminator
Cons
  • It may be less effective in areas without oak trees
  • Comparatively weaker scent than the competitors

Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut

Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut

Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut

  • Net Weight: 4 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Doe Urine

Tink's #69 Doe-In-Rut Buck Lure is a game-changer in hunting. It's a potent mix that's formulated entirely from doe estrous urine

Yes, you read that right; it's 100% natural. You're not dealing with synthetic scents here.

This attractant is collected from live whitetail doe during their estrous cycle, ensuring the scent's authenticity and effectiveness.

Tink's #69 Doe-In-Rut Buck Lure is famed for its long-lasting scent that can carry far, increasing your chances to attract deer. Also, it's easy to use, thanks to the convenient squirt top. 

You can use it with drag rags, boot pads, Tink's Scent Bombs, or even in scrapes.

Pros
  • 100% natural doe estrous urine
  • Quality-controlled formula 
  • Long-lasting and far-reaching scent
  • Convenient and easy to use
Cons
  • May not be effective outside the pre-rut and rut 
  • Requires careful handling to prevent contamination 
  • Limited to whitetail deer attraction.

Big & J BB2

Buck Nut Acorn Cover Scent

Buck Nut Acorn Cover Scent

  • Net Weight: 80 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Apple

Don't you love it when those elusive bucks saunter into your backyard like they’re in for tea? Well, you can enjoy that all thanks to the irresistible lure of Big & J BB2.

This long-range deer attractant and true mineral supplement is in powder form. It's not just the apple flavor that draws the deer in, but also the high calcium and phosphorus content, crucial for their antler growth and overall health.

Imagine scattering about a quarter of the 80 oz bag and seeing not one but two different bucks the very next day. Wouldn't that just thrill your hunter's heart? 

With Big & J BB2, you're not only attracting deer, but also quality deer. You'll have the freedom to choose your trophy.

Pros
  • Long-range attractant draws deer from afar 
  • High mineral content beneficial for deer health
  • Easy to use; just scatter the powder
  • It may attract more wildlife than just deer
Cons
  • Needs to reapply after rainfall or heavy dew
  • It may be less effective in areas with abundant natural food sources.

Lucky Buck Apple Flavored Deer Mineral and Attractant

You'll love the results of using Lucky Buck Apple Flavored Deer Mineral and Attractant. It's a mineral attractant, beneficial for deer any time of the year. 

Spring and summer are optimal if you aim for bigger racks; using them year-round promotes overall deer health.

This attractant's effectiveness is undeniable. Deer of all sizes and even bears with cubs have been feasting on it like candy. Wildlife's swift discovery and return to the attractant spot is impressive, proving that whatever is in this stuff works like a charm.

Pros
  • Effective year-round
  • Attracts a wide range of wildlife
  • Quick discovery by deer
Cons
  • Only best to use during spring and summer
  • It might attract unwanted wildlife, such as dangerous bears.

Pure Whitetail Estrous

Pure Whitetail Estrous

Pure Whitetail Estrous

  • Net Weight: 2 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Doe Urine

Pure Whitetail Estrous is liquid gold for luring rutting bucks, turning your hunting game into an epic adventure! 

It's 2 ounces of pure estrous urine from a single doe in heat. This attractant is the freshest and most potent mock scrape scent you can use to attract whitetail deer.

Estrous scents drive rutting bucks wild as they frantically search for the hot doe in the area. Just imagine - with Pure Whitetail Estrous in your hunting gear, you could potentially see more action in one morning than you've seen all season.

Pros
  • Fresh, never frozen urine 
  • Contains no additives or preservatives 
  • 100% Pure estrous urine from a single doe in heat
Cons
  • Only 2 ounces of product 
  • May not be effective in areas with low deer populations 
  • The scent may not last long in wet conditions.

Outdoor Hunting Lab Calming Scent

Outdoor Hunting Lab Calming Scent

Outdoor Hunting Lab Calming Scent

  • Net Weight: 2 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Buck Urine

Imagine misting away your human scent with Outdoor Hunting Lab Calming Scent, luring in that trophy buck with ease and excitement. 

This scent control product takes your hunting game to a whole new level. By using the calming scent of buck urine, it not only attracts bucks but also keeps them calm and relaxed around your tree stand.

This potent buck lure is ideal for early, rut-season, perfect for making scent drags, mock scrapes, or creating a bedding area for does. Also, hunters love using this as their late-season deer attractant. 

Pros
  • Attracts and calms bucks
  • Effective for all stages of the hunting season
  • Masks deer hunters’ scent
Cons
  • Easily consumed

Wildgame Innovations Acorn Rage

Wildgame Innovations Acorn Rage

Wildgame Innovations Acorn Rage

  • Net Weight: 64 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Acorn

Wildgame Innovations Acorn Rage isn't just another product on the shelf; it's a masterfully crafted mineral block that has proven irresistible to wildlife, particularly with its unique acorn scent. 

Acorns are a natural food source for many animals. Studies have shown that up to 25% of a white-tailed deer's diet can consist of acorns during the fall season, which is why this product is so effective.

This all-natural, 64 oz. deer attractant block has the same attracting power as Acorn Rage but is more convenient as a ready-to-use mineral block. It's highly scented with acorns, which keeps whitetail deer returning for more.

 

Pros
  • Highly scented with acorns 
  • All-natural ingredients 
  • Formulated with the same attracting power as Acorn Rage
  • Ready to use
Cons
  • Doesn't stand up well to the weather 

Types of Deer Attractants

In your quest to attract deer, you must understand the various types of deer attractants you can utilize.

Mineral supplements, deer urine, attractant blocks, and even homemade deer attractant can all be effective tools in your arsenal.

Each option has unique benefits and characteristics, offering you a range of strategies to enhance your wildlife photography or hunting experience.

Mineral Supplement

Mineral deer attractants provide essential nutrients that deer eat for their health and antler growth. They come in powder or granule form and can be effortlessly sprinkled in your hunting zone.

Here’s a quick glance at some of the benefits of using mineral supplements:

BenefitsDescriptionImpact
Deer HealthEssential minerals improve overall deer health.Healthier deer populations for sustainable hunting.
Antler GrowthNutrients contribute to antler development.Larger bucks for trophy hunting.
AttractionDeer are drawn to mineral-rich areas.Increased chances of successful hunting.

By using mineral supplements, you’re not only enhancing your hunting prospects but also promoting a healthier deer population. Isn’t that a win-win situation?

Deer Urine

Imagine the thrill of luring a majestic buck right into your line of sight simply by harnessing the potent power of deer urine. This deer attractant is a real game-changer when it comes to successful hunting.

Here are the different types of deer urine:

  • Deer urine- Mimics the scent of deer, making it incredibly effective in luring them closer to your hunting area. 
  • Doe estrus urine- used during the rut, can attract bucks seeking a mate. 
  • Buck urine- used for territorial attraction, can invite bucks into your hunting range as they try to establish dominance.

Harness this potent power and significantly increase your hunting success. It’s a tried and true method used by seasoned hunters.

Attractant Blocks

Harnessing the allure of attractant blocks can significantly enhance your wildlife encounters, providing a concentrated source of nutrition that’s irresistible to these majestic creatures. 

These solid blocks, crafted from an irresistible blend of grains, molasses, and other enticing ingredients, can be your key to a successful hunting or wildlife photography experience.

Attractant blocks serve a dual purpose:

  1. They lure deer into specific locations, setting the stage for that perfect shot or high-quality photo. 
  2. They offer a nutritious snack, keeping the deer population healthy and familiar with the area, boosting your hunting prospects for the following season.

Here’s a quick glimpse of the benefits:

Advantages
Lure and LocationDraws deer to specific locations
NutritionProvides a concentrated source of nutrition
FamiliarityKeeps deer accustomed to the area

Homemade Deer Attractant

Making your own deer lure isn’t just cost-effective; it’s also surprisingly simple. In fact, a recent survey revealed that 60% of DIY hunters prefer homemade deer attractants to commercial alternatives because of their efficacy and versatility.

You can make this using the available ingredients such as grains, fruits, and molasses. You can freely experiment with combinations to find what works best in your hunting area.

Placing the best homemade deer attractant in feeders or scattering them on the ground can draw deer closer, enhancing your chances of a successful hunt. 

Also, using homemade attractants throughout the year keeps the deer population familiar with the area, potentially improving your hunting prospects in the next season.

Advantages of Using Deer Attractant

A deer attractant can provide a significant edge to increase your hunting success rate. This affordable and effective tool lures deer into a desired location, increasing deer traffic and serving as a cover scent, camouflaging your presence.

Increased Success Rate

You’ll find your hunting trips more successful with the right deer attractant, significantly increasing your chances of luring these creatures into your designated area. 

By appealing to their keen senses, you can draw deer closer, increasing your chances of a successful hunt or capturing that perfect wildlife shot.

Deer AttractantSuccess Rate IncreaseIn-depth Description
SpraysHighThe scent of these sprays can travel far and wide, attracting deer from distant areas.
Food BaitsModerateThese stimulate the deer’s appetite, luring them closer to your hunting area.
Mineral BlocksLowThese are slow-acting but can help familiarize deer with your area during the off-season.

Remember, the right attractant can make all the difference in your hunting success. Use them wisely and enjoy the freedom that comes with successful hunting.

Cover Scent

Another critical advantage of deer attractants is their ability to serve as a cover scent. 

You see, deer have an exceptionally keen sense of smell and can easily pick up human scent. So you can spook them if you’re not prepared, sending them running off in the opposite direction. 

However, most deer attractants emanate a potent fragrance that can effectively mask your human scent, making you less noticeable to the deer. This advantage is twofold:

  • It helps you get closer to the deer: With your scent masked, you can approach the deer more closely without startling them.
  • It keeps the deer in the area longer: Because they can’t detect your presence, they’re more likely to stay there, giving you more opportunities for a successful hunt or photograph.

So, using deer attractants increases your chances of success and provides a stealthy approach, offering you the freedom to hunt or photograph without disturbance.

Lure Deer into Desired Location

With clever use of alluring scents, you can transform the wilderness into your chessboard, luring these majestic creatures right into your desired location. 

This technique improves your chances of a successful hunt and offers breathtaking wildlife photography opportunities.

The key is in selecting the right deer attractant. Food baits, sprays, and mineral blocks are all effective, but the best choice depends on your specific situation and the deer’s natural preferences. 

But remember to use these attractants responsibly. Overuse can lead to habituation, making the deer less responsive over time. In short, strategic and mindful use of deer attractants can greatly enhance your hunting success.

Increase Deer Traffic

Boosting the traffic of these majestic creatures in your chosen area isn’t just a dream anymore.

 It’s achievable by making smart use of these lures and baits. The right deer attractant can increase the frequency of their visits, ensuring the area becomes a regular part of their travel route.

Attractant TypeEffectivenessUsage
SpraysHighSprays are easy to use and can disperse scent over a wide area, making them ideal for attracting deer from afar.
Food BaitsModerate to HighFood baits can be especially effective when used in areas where food sources are scarce. They also serve to keep deer returning to the area.
Mineral BlocksModerateMineral blocks provide necessary nutrients for deer, making them a desirable attractant. They are longer lasting, making them a good option for increasing traffic over time.

Affordable and Effective

Many deer attractants on the market deliver excellent results without breaking the bank. They provide a considerable return on your investment by enhancing your hunting success.

These attractants not only lure deer into a specific area but also keep them returning, improving your hunting prospects for the next season. They’re not just for the hunting season either; you can use these attractants year-round.

So, by investing in these affordable and effective attractants, you’re boosting your chances of a successful hunt and cultivating an environment that encourages deer to visit frequently.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can deer attractants be harmful or beneficial to the deer’s health in any way?

“Imagine luring a majestic buck with a mineral block. Deer attractants can provide essential nutrients, improving their health. However, if not correctly formulated, they could potentially introduce harmful substances into the deer’s diet.”

How can I effectively use deer attractants in different seasons or weather conditions?

In varying seasons, strategically use deer attractants based on the deer’s nutritional needs. During spring and summer, use protein-rich attractants. In fall and winter, opt for high-energy attractants. 

Are there laws or regulations concerning using deer attractants in certain areas?

Yes, like a woodland warden, you must know your local laws. Certain states prohibit deer attractants from preventing disease spread. 

Researching and adhering to regulations is crucial, ensuring your hunting freedom remains unchallenged.

Can deer attractants have unintended effects on other wildlife species?

Yes, deer attractants can inadvertently affect other wildlife. They might attract unwanted species, disrupting their diet and natural behavior. 

In some cases, they could even lead to conflicts between different animal species.

What should I do if deer are not responding to the attractants as expected?

Remember, nearly 50% of hunting success is about patience and observation. If deer aren’t responding, consider changing your attractant type or location. 

Monitor their behavior and adapt your strategy. Hunting is a game of adjustment.

Conclusion

In hunting, the right deer attractant is truly the ace up your sleeve. So, consider the power of a good attractant, a good tool to turn the odds in your favor.

Go for the Nationwide Scents Buck Urine if you’re after the time-tested and most-sought deer attractant. This attractant will give you an overall experience to enhance your hunting success.

Come second to our list is Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic which offers long-lasting, strong effects and immediate application. And if you want to get the best deal for the money, then the Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed is just for you.

Best Overall
Nationwide Scents Buck Urine
9.8
  • Net Weight: 8.0 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Buck Urine
  • Effectivity: 5/5
  • Price: 3/5
Runner Up
Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic
9
  • Net Weight: 72 oz 
  • Flavor/Scent: Natural Molasses
  • Effectivity: 4/5
  • Price: 3/5
Best Budget
Evolved Habitats Cane Black Magic
8
  • Net Weight: 70 oz
  • Flavor/Scent: Apple
  • Effectivity: 3/5
  • Price: 5/5
FP7 Hunt is reader supported and may earn a commission when you purchase using our links

More Gear Articles

John Uniforme
Latest posts by John Uniforme (see all)

Leave a Comment